Best toastie maker for delicious toasted sandwiches

Upgrade your toasted sandwiches with our pick of the best toastie makers.

Best toastie maker

by Rosie Floyd |
Updated on

The best toastie maker is sure to be an essential kitchen appliance for any home that just loves toasted sandwiches. Sure, you could use a top-notch toaster to toast up a couple of slices of bread for you and put your chosen ingredients inside to create a hearty sandwich, but it’s not quite the same as sinking your teeth into a crunchy and crispy toastie, that’s sealed around the edges with a delightfully warm filling inside. With our pick of fantastic toasted sandwich makers, you'll be able to whip up this incredibly delicious light bite as soon as the craving hits.

These days, lots of the best toastie makers are able to create more than just toasted sandwiches. Many are designed to double up as waffle makers and some even have three-in-one functionality, allowing them to be used as household grills, too. By using interchangeable plates or additional accessories, you can unleash your creativity in the kitchen and make a whole host of sweet and savoury snacks and meals to tempt your tastebuds whenever hunger strikes. While they may not be available in a wide range of colours and finishes, as a matching kettle and toaster set might be, they more than make up for it by being a versatile kitchen gadget that can replace the functionality of multiple appliances.

When buying a sandwich toaster, there are a number of factors you'll want to consider. Firstly, you'll want to think about the size and capacity of your chosen model, ensuring it can accommodate the bread size, the amount of filling you desire and the number of toasties you'll want to make at a time. If your household regularly uses up all the slots on a four-slice toaster when making breakfast in the morning, you'll want to pick up one of the larger models to make toasties for the whole family at once. Other things to look out for are adjustable temperature settings, allowing you to control the level of toasting according to your preference, a non-stick surface for easy cleanup, and safety features, like cool-touch handles and auto-shut-off functions to prevent accidents.

Best toastie makers at a glance:

Best overall: Salter EK2143 3-in-1 Snack Maker – View on Amazon UK
Best 3-in-1 toastie maker: Ninja Foodi 3-in-1 Toaster, Grill & Panini Press ST202UK – View on Ninja Kitchen
Best deep-fill toastie maker: Cuisinart Overstuffed Toasted Sandwich Maker – View on Lakeland

To help you decide which sandwich maker to get, we've searched the web to find all the best toastie makers that offer a range of functions and also are equipped with great features that will revolutionise your toastie-making game. All the toastie makers in our list have been chosen as they come highly rated by real-life customers online or have been tried and tested by experts on the Yours shopping team.

Best toastie makers

Best overall

Promising to deliver perfectly toasted toasties in around four minutes, with the ability to cook paninis and waffles, too, there's no wonder that the Salter EK2143 3-in-1 Snack Maker is highly rated on Amazon with over 10,000 reviews and an average rating of 4.4 stars. Its plates are extra large so you can toast big sandwiches and paninis as well as make thick waffles and the handle is cool to the touch so you shouldn't burn yourself when checking to see whether your snacks and meals are finished.

Customer review: "I'd wanted a sandwich maker, but without spending a fortune, and this is just the job. Arrived today and put to use for a late lunch. Toasted a nice tuna sandwich in around 4 mins. The clip-lock system is great too as means the sandwich is toasted together, unlike other models that can leave sandwiches coming out and dropping their fillings as you eat! Great being able to store it upright too, and power easy to manage with red and green lights to show you when it's ready to use. Would recommend."


  • Three interchangeable non-stick plates
  • Extra large cooking plate size


  • Short power cord

Best 3-in-1 toastie maker

Combining the performance of a slot toaster with the versatility of a grill and the convenience of a panini press, the Ninja Foodi 3-in-1 Toaster, Grill & Panini Press is a toastie maker that really can do it all. You can create your perfect toastie in a matter of minutes using the clever Panini Press accessory, but that's not all. It's got seven cooking functions, toast, bagel, defrost, grill, panini, bake and reheat so you can great a whole variety of meals and snacks to satisfy your cravings.

Customer review: "Daughter loves a toastie and this 3-in-1 does it all as well as space-saving no need for an extra machine"


  • Much more than just a toastie maker as it's a toaster and grill too
  • Separate Panini Press accessory


  • Perhaps not for you if you're after a simple toastie maker

Best deep-fill toastie maker

If you're someone who likes a lot of filling in your toasties, the Cuisinart Overstuffed Toasted Sandwich Maker has extra-large sandwich plates with deep pockets so you can pack a lot in. These big plates also mean you can use thicker breads for your toasted sandwiches, such as focaccia and ciabatta. The plates are also non-stick and removable so you can take them out to give a good clean and even pop them in the dishwasher.

Customer review: "Deciding to replace our previous sandwich toaster with this one! We have enjoyed omelettes, toasties and also pastries made using this machine. It has deep fill plates which ensures room for various fillings without spillages. The plates are easy to remove and clean which is a real bonus. Highly recommended!"


  • Deep plates for thick sandwiches and different breads
  • Can also be used to cook omelettes and turnovers


  • One or two reviewers had issues with the handle snapping after a year or two of owning it

Best budget toastie maker

You can enjoy delicious toasted snacks for a great price when using the Breville Sandwich/Panini Press & Toastie Maker. It's perfect for toasting paninis, ciabattas, tea cakes and crumpets as well as for warming pittas, tortillas and naan breads with large plates offering space for cooking up to three sandwiches to perfection each time. The floating top plate is designed to accommodate different sandwich thicknesses and rest firmly on the bread for even toasting.

Customer review: "This is the best sandwich maker I have owned takes no time to heat up and everything I have toasted has come out brilliantly highly recommend."


  • Compact design for easy storage
  • Non-stick plates


  • Can only be switched on/off by the mains plug

Best waffle and toastie maker

Tasty toasties aren't the only thing you can make with the Russell Hobbs 3in1 Sandwich, Panini & Waffle Maker 24540 - it also makes mouthwatering waffles as well as grilled delights. Its versatility means you can create a whole variety of sweet and savoury snacks. The removable plates make it easy to switch between the sandwiches, waffles or the grill plates and it also makes clean-ups as painless as possible, too.

Customer review: "Really simple to use. Great little instruction booklet with recipe ideas in. Toasty maker is a good size fits standard bread in. Seems easy to clean so far and has extra parts for cooking waffles too. Heats up quickly and toastys are done in around 4 minutes. Really happy with the purchase."


  • Removable plates
  • Versatile cooking


  • Just one heat setting

Best steel toastie maker

With an innovative hinge design, the Sage SSG600BSS Perfect Press Sandwich Maker ensures you have a crisp, fluffy sandwich by making sure the outside is deliciously toasted using just the right amount of pressure without squashing what's inside. Made using brushed stainless steel to give it that modern, clean look, it has a compact design so it won't take up much room on your kitchen sides and comes complete with a storage clip so you can easily store it when not in use.

Customer review: "This Sage sandwich maker is really the business. I was originally buying (when I could get hold of them!) the M&S cheese & ham pre-made toasted sandwiches which were getting close on to £5.00 per kick. Due to their lack of availability, along with escalating price, I went for the Sage Sandwich Maker and to be honest - what a good job I did. The toasties that come out of this machine are far better than M&S - ok - you have the trouble of doing your own - but they are far better. I make up a batch (cheese & ham) - freeze them and then when I want a toastie - simply defrost and put into the Sage Machine - complete magic and in the long run - very much cheaper. Highly recommended - a dream to clean (when hot get a piece of kitchen towel and wipe the plates clean) cracking toasties (coat plates with a little veg oil to crisp up the bread) and personally I would no longer pay for the pre-made versions."


  • Space-saving and easy storage design
  • Adjustable height control


  • Heavier than some at 3.4kg

Best grill for making toasties

The George Foreman 25820 Large Fit Grill will be predominantly used for grilling meat and vegetables but it can also make a pretty mean, lean toasted sandwich. This roomy grill uses up to 88 per cent less energy than using your conventional oven grill, heating up 160 per cent faster and allowing you to enjoy freshly cooked food quickly while reducing energy and costs on your household bills. With non-stick coating and a clip-in drip tray, it also has a floating hinge for thicker cuts.

Reviewed by Features & Reviews Editor Emily Gilbert: "George Foreman is my go-to brand when it comes to toastie makers and I'm really impressed by the Fit Grill. We have the large version which means you can toast multiple sandwiches at once and we've also used it for grilling meat for dinner. It's so easy to clean and I love how little room it takes up in our cupboard despite the large size."


  • Speedy heat up
  • Easy to clean


  • Not a traditional toastie maker although it does a pretty good job

Our verdict: What is the best toastie maker?

In our opinion, the best toastie maker is the Salter EK2143 3-in-1 Snack Maker. We love that it's got extra large plates so it can accommodate a deeply filled toasted sandwich without worrying about the filling spilling out. It also offers a quick toasting time and safety features, such as a cool touch handle. Not only that but it can also be used as a grill and a waffle maker, thanks to the separate interchangeable non-stick plates, so you’re getting three-in-one functionality for way under £50.


How do you use a toastie maker?

Every toastie maker is different, so the best way to use your toasted sandwich maker will be to follow the instructions provided. The key is to follow each step.

One of our top tips is to butter both sides of the bread to make your sandwich more crispy.

Can you wash a toastie maker?

Yes, you will need to wash a toastie maker after every use. Before you start to clean, make sure you turn off and unplug this from the mains. Then leave to cool down. Once this has cooled down, you'll be able to clean the sandwich maker with warm soapy water.

Many models have removable and interchangeable plates that you can pop in the sink to wipe clean. Some plates can even be popped in the dishwasher, but you should always check the instructions of your chosen maker before doing that as non-stick coatings can be ruined by a cycle in the dishwasher.

Can toastie makers create waffles?

We couldn't believe it either, but some of the best toastie makers can also make waffles. A handful can also be used as grills so you can make so much more than just your favourite toasted sandwiches. These types of toastie makers will come with different plates so you can get creative in the kitchen, but if your chosen model doesn't come with a waffle plate, you won't be able to make them with it, unfortunately.

Rosie Floyd is a Pets, Homes and Garden Product Writer for Yours, specialising in home appliances, décor and furnishings, as well as all things dogs. After completing her Journalism & Media degree from Coventry University back in 2015, she started her career writing about must-visit holiday destinations, moving on to creating content around outdoor living and garden buildings, before joining the team at Bauer.


Just so you know, whilst we may receive a commission or other compensation from the links on this website, we never allow this to influence product selections - read why you should trust us